Tuesday, May 5, 2020

Environmental Secrets Uncovered in Museum Bird Collections


I had the good fortune recently to accompany members of the local Audubon Society on a behind-the-scenes tour of the bird collection at the University of Michigan Museum of Natural History. The Audubon Society, according to their website, has a mission “to protect birds and the places they need, now and tomorrow.”  You can find more about the Audubon Society, here


Figure 1. Bird skins, UM Museum of Natural History.  Photo Credit: Emily Thompson.
You might wonder, then, what is in a museum bird collection?  Surprisingly, the things collected and saved since the late 1800's are not just birds, but nests, eggs, wings, skeletons and the skins of whole birds. Other things collected and saved include stomach contents and parasites. Specimens used to be collected by shooting the birds. Now, however, specimens are usually added to the collection after they're killed accidentally, perhaps by hitting a window or being hit by a car.  


Figure 2.  Bird Nest, UM Museum of Natural History. Photo Credit: Emily Thompson.

Why would birders, who love living birds, be interested in a collection of dead birds?  One reason is the collections are used for important conservation research.  For example, bird collections were used in the study of the effects of DDT on eggshell strength that helped lead to the publication of Rachel Carson’s ground-breaking book, Silent Spring. This book in turn lead to a ban on the use of DDT in the U.S. Bird collections are also used in forensic research to determine which bird species caused a specific airplane crash.  What follows are two examples of the benefits of bird collections.  

From the Egg Collections: Conservation Studies
Figure 3.  Bird Eggs, UM Museum of Natural History.  Photo Credit: Emily Thompson.
According to John Bates at the Field Museum i nChicago, Illinois, the most important study arising from bird collections was published in October of 1968 by Hickey and Anderson in the journal Science. Their paper is considered to be one of the most important scientific papers of all times, and it describes the effect of the pesticide DDT on eggshell thickness compared with no-DDT control eggs. At the time, DDT was being widely sprayed to kill the mosquitoes that spread diseases like malaria.  These scientists studied the peregrine falcon eggshells from areas that were sprayed (from the Field Museum in Chicago, IL) and compared them with peregrine falcon eggshells from areas that were not sprayed (from the Charlotte Islands, British Columbia, Canada). The results showed the eggshells in Illinois thinned after spraying with DDT while the eggshells in the Charlotte Islands area showed no change in the same time period. (more information here).  The result of weakened eggshells was declining numbers of peregrine falcon and other birds of prey (such as the American eagle) due to breeding failure, because weak eggshells caused embryo death. The study of Hickey and Anderson was key to Rachel Carson’s argument that indiscriminate spraying of DDT would lead to a “silent spring” where birds would no longer sing. The result of the study, coupled with Carson’s book was the banning of DDT and greater environmental awareness.  You can find more, here  and here

From the Collections: Forensics Studies
Figure 4.  Bird Skeleton, UM Museum of Natural History.  Photo Credit: Emily Thompson.

When a bird strikes an airplane, causing a crash, the authorities want to know what species brought down the plane.  The ultimate goal is to avoid future accidents, and by knowing what type of bird is involved, they can design airports, engines and airplanes to reduce bird strikes.  The bird remains, often just  a feather or bird bits called “sparge” are often sent to forensic ornithologist Carla Dove at the Smithsonian Institute. There, she and her staff identify the bird causing the bird strike by comparing its remains to samples in the huge bird and feather collections of the Smithsonian.  Additionally, they perform DNA analysis and  microscopic analysis. Here’s a study from 2009 of identification of remains of an American white pelican involved in the crash of a Cessna.   

If you like the idea of looking through museum collections, try this website from the American Museum of Natural History  in New York.  They have videos of what it’s like to open up the drawers and cabinets in the museum and what scientists are using the collections for.

This blogpost was written for the benefit of students at Washtenaw Community College and the community as part of my sabbatical activities for winter 2020.  I am solely responsible for the content and hold the copyright for the work. Feel free to use the information in this blog; just credit me with a link back to my blog! -Emily Thompson, Ph.D.